Skip to content
parteiprogramm

Grüne on public safety

From the program “For Our Beautiful Bavaria”

2023 Bavaria state election, October 8, 2023Original PDF, 103 pagesAnalyzed on October 3, 2026

AIThe summaries and placements on this page were written by AI. No person reviews each one. How they are made

Placement on Public safety

Average of the points on this page. The placement is made by AI.

Each axis measures one topic. There is no single "left" or "right" for everything here: economy, society, migration and security are kept apart. Only what the program says is placed. How to read the placement

  • Economyleaning more state (-1), from 1 point

    Points per step: 0 clearly more state, 1 leaning more state, 0 balanced, 0 leaning more market, 0 clearly more market

  • Civil liberties and securityleaning civil liberties first (-0.6), from 7 points

    Points per step: 1 clearly civil liberties first, 4 leaning civil liberties first, 0 balanced, 2 leaning security and order first, 0 clearly security and order first

  • Europeleaning more EU (-1), from 1 point

    Points per step: 0 clearly more EU, 1 leaning more EU, 0 balanced, 0 leaning less EU, 0 clearly less EU

The small columns under the bars show how many points sit on each of the five steps.

End fixed border checks, dissolve border police

The Greens want to end the fixed checks at internal EU borders that have been in place since 2015 and replace them with mobile checks. The Bavarian border police would be dissolved because, in their view, border protection is a federal task. This is meant to ease the burden on people and businesses in border regions.

Bavaria's borders have had fixed checks since 2015. The Greens want to end them. Police should do mobile checks instead. The Bavarian border police should no longer exist. Bavaria should work more closely with Czechia and Austria.

The platform describes the border closures during the Covid pandemic and the fixed checks as a burden on border regions. Mobile checks are meant to focus police resources on especially serious crime. Cooperation with Czechia and Austria would be expanded, including through an exchange platform modeled on the Lake Constance Conference. Euroregions and similar cross-border bodies would receive basic funding.

Show the original quote (page 84)
„Die Sicherung der Staatsgrenze ist Bundessache, daher werden wir die bayerische Grenzpolizei auflösen.“

Translation: Securing the national border is a federal matter, so we will dissolve the Bavarian border police.

Page 84 in the original

Placement

  • Civil liberties and securityleaning civil liberties first

    Fixed border checks and a state police unit would go while mobile checks remain, which reduces the presence of security agencies step by step.

  • Europeleaning more EU

    Ending fixed internal border checks and expanding cross-border cooperation strengthens open borders within the Schengen area.

No blanket data retention on soccer fans

The Greens reject storing data on soccer fans without a specific reason, noting that civil rights also apply inside the stadium. Fan projects are to receive long-term funding. A pilot project is to test reducing police presence at professional games depending on the situation.

The Greens say the state should not store data on soccer fans without a reason. Fan projects should get steady money. At some games there should be fewer police officers. The party wants to test this first.

The platform keeps the goal of a safe stadium visit for everyone. To that end, Bavarian fan projects are to get reliable, lasting funding. Cooperation and communication among everyone involved in soccer games are to improve. The reduced police presence is to depend on the situation at each game and will first run as a pilot project.

Show the original quote (page 93)
„Daher lehnen wir die anlasslose Speicherung der Daten von Fußballfans ab.“

Translation: That is why we reject the storage of soccer fans' data without specific cause.

Page 93 in the original

Placement

  • Civil liberties and securityleaning civil liberties first

    Rejecting data storage without cause and testing a reduced police presence give privacy and civil rights somewhat more weight than today.

Give police more staff and modern equipment

The Greens want more police staff and modern technology across Bavaria and want to relieve officers of tasks outside law enforcement. They also plan to step up the fight against organized crime, cybercrime and child abuse.

The Greens want more police officers and better technology. Police should have fewer tasks that are not police work. They should do more against crime on the internet. They should also do more against gangs and child abuse.

The investment backlog in equipment and police buildings is to be cleared, training modernized and regular further training made standard. The party wants more IT specialists and a virtual police station for filing reports online. It plans a state package against organized crime, including money laundering, and more action against online hate. People considered dangerous would be closely monitored and their networks exposed. Cooperation with authorities abroad and in other German states would be intensified, and diversity and the protection of women from violence would be supported.

Show the original quote (page 98)
„Wir sorgen flächendeckend für mehr Personal und moderne Polizeitechnik.“

Translation: We will provide more staff and modern police technology across the state.

Page 98 in the original

Placement

  • Civil liberties and securityleaning security and order first

    More staff, technology and closer monitoring of dangerous individuals strengthen the security authorities step by step within the existing framework.

Reform the police powers law, limit surveillance

The Greens want to change Bavaria's Polizeiaufgabengesetz (police powers law), abolish preventive detention and remove the term "impending danger." The party rejects blanket surveillance such as data retention without cause because it sees civil liberties at risk.

The Greens want to change the police law in Bavaria. Nobody should be locked up for weeks as a precaution. Police should not watch everyone without a reason. The party wants to protect people's freedom.

The party regards police powers far ahead of a concrete danger as an unconstitutional move toward intelligence-service methods and is suing before the Bavarian Constitutional Court. It also rejects a blanket expansion of video surveillance, source telecommunications surveillance (reading encrypted messages on the device) and software that predicts crimes. Automated data analysis would be allowed only with a clear legal basis and strict oversight, and police software handling personal data would run only on state-owned servers. Tasers would be reserved for special units. The Greens also plan a freedom of assembly law and want to keep police and domestic intelligence separate.

Show the original quote (page 102)
„Auch die Präventivhaft, bei der Menschen bis zu zwei Monate schon bei der bloßen Gefahr der Begehung von Ordnungswidrigkeiten eingesperrt werden können, werden wir abschaffen.“

Translation: We will also abolish preventive detention, under which people can be locked up for up to two months merely because of a risk that they might commit administrative offenses.

Page 102 in the original

Placement

  • Civil liberties and securityclearly civil liberties first

    Abolishing preventive detention and the "impending danger" concept and rejecting data retention fundamentally cut back existing police powers.

Tighten oversight of police and domestic intelligence

The Greens want individual identification for uniformed police officers, an independent police commissioner and a study on racism within the security authorities. Bavaria's domestic intelligence office is also to be reformed and placed under stronger parliamentary oversight.

The Greens want uniformed police officers to wear a personal ID. An independent office should check the police. A study should look at racism in the security agencies. Parliament should watch the intelligence office more closely.

The police commissioner would have powers to investigate. During identity checks, state police would have to give the reason in writing on request, in line with rules planned for the federal police. The party expects this to improve how mistakes are handled and to build trust between the public and the police. For the domestic intelligence office, the annual report would be prepared together with researchers and the system of informants would be reformed.

Show the original quote (page 98)
„Mit uns gibt es die individuelle Kennzeichnung für uniformierte Polizeibeamt*innen“

Translation: With us, there will be individual identification for uniformed police officers

Page 98 in the original

Placement

  • Civil liberties and securityleaning civil liberties first

    Mandatory identification, independent oversight and more parliamentary control strengthen citizens' rights vis-à-vis the security authorities.

Pursue right-wing extremism more forcefully

The Greens see right-wing extremism as currently the greatest threat to internal security in Bavaria and want tougher action against the scene. Right-wing extremists and Reichsbürger (people who reject the German state) are to be disarmed, vigilante groups stopped and exit programs greatly expanded.

The Greens see right-wing extremism as the biggest danger in Bavaria. Police should go after right-wing extremists more. They should not have weapons anymore. There should be more help for people who want to leave the scene.

Security agencies would get more digital analysis capacity to detect radicalization on social networks and forums. The search for extremists in hiding would be stepped up and outstanding arrest warrants enforced. Suspected violent right-wing offenders would be reviewed systematically using the risk assessment tool already applied to Islamist offenders. The party wants to examine bans on neo-Nazi groups and use association law against vigilante groups. Statewide protection plans are foreseen for refugee housing, synagogues and mosques. The recommendations of the NSU inquiry committees are also to be carried out.

Show the original quote (page 99)
„Den Ermittlungs- und Fahndungsdruck auf die rechtsextreme Szene werden wir deutlich erhöhen.“

Translation: We will significantly increase the investigative and search pressure on the right-wing extremist scene.

Page 99 in the original

Placement

  • Civil liberties and securityleaning security and order first

    More search pressure, digital analysis, closer monitoring and disarmament expand the work of security agencies within the existing legal framework.

Expand disaster protection and warning systems

The Greens want to better equip fire departments, rescue services and disaster protection because, in their view, the climate crisis means more emergencies. Public warnings, emergency supplies and the protection of critical infrastructure are also to be improved.

The Greens want stronger disaster protection. Fire departments and rescue services should get better equipment. There should be more sirens in Bavaria. Every town should know what happens in heavy rain.

Higher funding rates and help with tenders are meant to encourage municipalities to buy rescue equipment jointly. Plans include more training places and instructors, childcare and online training for responders, and a campaign to recruit women, people with a migration background and people with disabilities. The party wants to invest in battery-powered sirens and make crisis communication accessible and multilingual. A funding program would pay for heavy-rain modeling for every municipality. Emergency supplies of water, medicine, food, mobile coverage and electricity are to be expanded.

Show the original quote (page 100)
„Wir stärken deshalb die kommunale Gefahrenabwehr und den Katastrophenschutz, statten sie besser aus und fördern aktiv die bessere Verzahnung mit dem Zivilschutz.“

Translation: We will therefore strengthen municipal emergency response and disaster protection, equip them better and actively promote closer integration with civil defense.

Page 100 in the original

Placement

  • Economyleaning more state

    Higher funding rates, new funding programs and public investment in equipment and infrastructure expand public services.

Focus the prison system on rehabilitation

The Greens want to gear the prison system more toward reintegration and draft a rehabilitation law for that purpose. The program argues that the best protection against new crimes is when released prisoners do not reoffend.

The Greens want to help prisoners return to normal life. There would be a new law for this. There would be more therapy and more open prisons. That way fewer people should commit crimes again.

Plans include better medical care in prisons, more say for inmates and more ways to stay in contact with relatives. Pay for working prisoners would be brought in line with the minimum wage. The party also wants to strengthen victim-offender mediation, involve victims at every stage of proceedings and expand victim support through existing structures.

Show the original quote (page 101)
„Deswegen stellen wir das Resozialisierungsziel im Strafvollzug klar in den Vordergrund und sorgen für mehr Therapieangebote und mehr offenen Vollzug.“

Translation: That is why we will clearly put the goal of rehabilitation first in the prison system and provide more therapy options and more open prisons.

Page 101 in the original

Placement

  • Civil liberties and securityleaning civil liberties first

    More open prisons, therapy and inmate rights shift the prison system step by step toward milder conditions.

Better protect emergency responders from violence

The Greens want a package of measures to protect rescue workers, firefighters and police from attacks. The focus is on prevention, since the program names alcohol as the most common cause of such violence.

The Greens want to protect helpers from violence. This means paramedics, firefighters and police officers. Alcohol is often the reason for attacks. So there should be more prevention.

Violence prevention would be targeted at alcohol and at specific groups. A statewide situation report would break down the offenses, and a study would capture unreported cases. Responders would get more training in de-escalation and self-defense. Additional counseling services are planned for those affected.

Show the original quote (page 102)
„Außerdem weiten wir die Aus- und Weiterbildungsmaßnahmen zur Deeskalation und Selbstverteidigung der Helfer*innen aus.“

Translation: In addition, we will expand basic and further training in de-escalation and self-defense for the helpers.

Page 102 in the original

Placement

This point touches none of the axes.

What do the other parties say on public safety?

All programs in Bavaria compared